Stayability (STAY) presents limitations in capturing genetic variability among animals with varying calving records up to 76 months of age. Furthermore, because STAY is measured late in life (typically at 6 years of age), it inherently prolongs generation intervals. To address this limitation, we evaluated an alternative approach using random regression models, which incorporate multiple phenotypes recorded throughout an animal's lifespan to generate predictive curves for breeding values. Using calving records from 179,001 Nellore cows, we compared two phenotypic expressions of longevity and aimed to identify the optimal random regression model for predicting breeding values. Ten specific ages were defined for functional longevity expressed as stayability (FLSTAY). At each age, a binary phenotype (1 or 0) was assigned based on whether the cow remained in the herd. Alternatively, for functional longevity associated with the number of calvings (FLNC), the cumulative number of calvings recorded up to each specific age was calculated. Models fitting Legendre orthogonal polynomials ranging from linear to cubic degrees were compared. The cubic polynomial proved most suitable for modelling FLSTAY, whereas the quadratic polynomial provided the best fit for FLNC. Predictive ability metrics of estimated breeding values for FLNC were superior to those for FLSTAY. Heritability estimates for FLNC (0.025-0.074) were consistently higher than those for FLSTAY (0.004-0.045). Similarly, genetic correlations across ages were generally stronger for FLNC, reaching 0.88 between 39 and 75 months (the traditional age for selection). These findings suggest the feasibility of applying random regression models to FLNC, allowing its use as an early selection strategy to improve functional longevity.
Genetic Evaluation for Functional Longevity in Nellore Cattle.
TL;DR
Stayability (STAY) presents limitations in capturing genetic variability among animals with varying calving records up to 76 months of age. Furthermore, because STAY is measured late in life (typically at 6 years of age), it inherently prolongs generation intervals. To address this limitation, we evaluated an alternative approach using random regression models, which incorporate multiple phenotypes recorded throughout an animal's lifespan to generate predictive curves for breeding values. Using
Credibility Assessment
Preliminary — 38/100
Study Design
Rigor of the research methodology
5/20
Sample Size
Whether the study was sufficiently powered
7/20
Peer Review
Review status and journal reputation
10/20
Replication
Has this finding been independently reproduced?
6/20
Transparency
Funding disclosure and data availability
10/20
Overall
Sum of all five dimensions
38/100
0 Comments
Log in to join the discussion.